Comment on "Infrared signature of the superconducting gap symmetry in iron-arsenide superconductors", Y. M. Dai et al. arXiv:1106.4430

Abstract

Y. M. Dai et al. in their recent work arXiv:1106.4430 presented a reflectivity study of the in-plance optical conductivity of a $\textrm{Ba}_{0.6}\textrm{K}_{0.4}\textrm{Fe}_2\textrm{As}_2$ (BKFA) superconductor with $T_{\textrm{c}}\approx39K$. The single crystals used in this study are of high quality and the measurements are rather accurate. The authors analyzed the optical conductivity of BKFA in the framework of the Mattis-Bardeen theory and the BCS theory of superconductivity. This analysis, however, generates a series of severe contradictions with a large body of experimental data obtained with multiple probes as well as misuses both the Mattis-Bardeen and the BCS theories of superconductivity beyond their approximation regions.