Comment on "Linear and passive silicon optical isolator" in Scientific Reports 2, 674

Abstract

Wang et al. [1] demonstrated different power transmission coefficients for forward and backward propagation in simulation and experiment. From such a demonstration, the central claim of their paper is that "the spatial inversion symmetry breaking diode can construct an optical isolator in no conflict with any reciprocal principle". Their claim contradicts the Lorentz reciprocity theorem, from which it is well known that one cannot construct an isolator this way.