Entropy production for velocity-dependent macroscopic forces: the problem of dissipation without fluctuations

Abstract

In macroscopic systems, velocity-dependent phenomenological forces $F(v)$ are used to model friction, feedback devices or self-propulsion. Such forces usually include a dissipative component which conceals the fast energy exchanges with a thermostat at the environment temperature $T$, ruled by a microscopic Hamiltonian $H$. The mapping $(H,T) \to F(v)$ - even if effective for many purposes - may lead to applications of stochastic thermodynamics where an $incomplete$ fluctuating entropy production (FEP) is derived. An enlightening example is offered by recent macroscopic experiments where dissipation is dominated by solid-on-solid friction, typically modelled through a deterministic Coulomb force $F(v)$. Through an adaptation of the microscopic Prandtl-Tomlinson model for friction, we show how the FEP is dominated by the heat released to the $T$-thermostat, ignored by the macroscopic Coulomb model. This problem, which haunts several studies in the literature, cannot be cured by weighing the time-reversed trajectories with a different auxiliary dynamics: it is only solved by a more accurate stochastic modelling of the thermostat underlying dissipation.