A Cautionary Note on the Zagarola and Smits Similarity Parameter for the Turbulent Boundary Layer

Abstract

Zagarola and Smits developed an empirical velocity parameter for scaling the outer region of the turbulent boundary layer velocity profile that has been widely applied to experimental datasets. Plots of the scaled defect profiles indicate that most datasets display similar-like behavior using the Zagarola and Smits scaling parameter. In the work herein, it is shown that the common practice of finding similarity behavior using the defect profile is often incomplete in the sense that not all of the criteria for similarity have been checked for compliance. When full compliance is checked, it is found that most of the datasets which display defect similarity do not satisfy all the criteria required for similarity. The nature of this contradiction and noncompliance is described in detail. It is shown that the original datasets used by Zagarola and Smits display this flawed similarity behavior. Hence, a careful reassessment of any claims in the literature is required for those groups that attempted to use the defect profile and the Zagarola and Smits type of velocity scaling parameter to assert similarity of the velocity profile.