Model theory and metric convergence I: Metastability and dominated convergence

Abstract

We study Tao's finitary viewpoint of convergence in metric spaces, as captured by the notion of metastability. We adopt the perspective of continuous model theory. We show that, in essence, metastable convergence with a given rate is the only formulation of metric convergence that can be captured by a theory in continuous first-order logic, a result we call the Uniform Metastability Principle. Philosophically, this principle amounts to the following meta-theorem: "If a classical statement about convergence in metric structures is refined to a statement about metastable convergence with some rate, then the validity of the original statement implies the validity of its metastable version." As an instance of this phenomenon, we formulate an abstract version of Tao's Metastable Dominated Convergence Theorem as a statement about axiomatizable classes of metric structures, and show that it is a direct consequence of the Uniform Metastability Principle.