Renormalization in large-$N$ QCD is incompatible with open/closed string duality

Abstract

Solving by a canonical string theory, of closed strings for the glueballs and open strings for the mesons, the 't Hooft large-$N$ expansion of QCD is a long-standing problem that resisted all the attempts despite the advent of the celebrated gauge/gravity duality in the framework of string theory. We demonstrate that in the canonical string framework such a solution does not actually exist because an inconsistency arises between the renormalization properties of the QCD S matrix at large $N$ -- a consequence of the asymptotic freedom (AF) -- and the open/closed duality of the would-be string solution. Specifically, the would-be open-string one-loop corrections to the tree glueball amplitudes must be ultraviolet (UV) divergent. Hence, naively, the inconsistency arises because these amplitudes are dual to tree closed-string diagrams, which are universally believed to be both UV finite -- since they are closed-string tree diagrams -- and infrared finite because of the glueball mass gap. In fact, the inconsistency follows from a low-energy theorem of the NSVZ type that controls the renormalization in QCD-like theories. The inconsistency extends to the would-be canonical string for a vast class of 't Hooft large-$N$ QCD-like theories including $\mathcal{N}=1$ SUSY QCD. We also demonstrate that the presently existing SUSY string models with a mass gap -- such as Klebanov-Strassler, Polchinski-Strassler (PS) and certain PS variants -- cannot contradict the above-mentioned results since they are not asymptotically free. Moreover, we shed light on the way the open/closed string duality may be perturbatively realized in these string models compatibly with a mass gap in the 't Hooft-planar closed-string sector and the low-energy theorem because of the lack of AF. Finally, we suggest a noncanonical way-out for QCD-like theories based on topological strings on noncommutative twistor space.