How an incorrect transition from finite to infinite 2D conductor may result in a false negative relaxation

Abstract

We consider the relaxation of a uniform current in a planar 2D conductor with account taken of electromagnetic retardation effects. If the 2D conductivity is larger than the speed of light, the straightforward solution for an infinite plane gives a negative relaxation rate. However if one starts from a conducting cylinder of finite radius and then increases it to infinity, the relaxation rate just tends to zero while remaining positive. We suggest that recent unusual plasmon-dispersion curves obtained by V. A. Volkov and A. A. Zabolotnykh [arXiv:1605.00430] result from the incorrect finite-to-infinite transition.