On overfitting and post-selection uncertainty assessments

Abstract

In a regression context, when the relevant subset of explanatory variables is uncertain, it is common to use a data-driven model selection procedure. Classical linear model theory, applied naively to the selected sub-model, may not be valid because it ignores the selected sub-model's dependence on the data. We provide an explanation of this phenomenon, in terms of overfitting, for a class of model selection criteria.