Prediction intervals for random-effects meta-analysis: a confidence distribution approach

Abstract

Prediction intervals are commonly used in meta-analysis with random-effects models. One widely used method, the Higgins-Thompson-Spiegelhalter prediction interval, replaces the heterogeneity parameter with its point estimate, but its validity strongly depends on a large sample approximation. This is a weakness in meta-analyses with few studies. We propose an alternative based on bootstrap and show by simulations that its coverage is close to the nominal level, unlike the Higgins-Thompson-Spiegelhalter method and its extensions. The proposed method was applied in three meta-analyses.