The double blue straggler sequence in NGC 2173: a field contamination artefact?

Abstract

Li et al. (2018) (hereafter L18) detected two apparently distinct populations of blue straggler stars (BSSs) in the young globular cluster NGC 2173, a similar feature as observed in numerous Galactic globular clusters (GCs). Recently, Dalessandro et al. (2018) (D18) compared the observed color--magnitude diagrams (CMDs) of both the cluster and a nearby reference field (although observed with the ACS/WFC instrument). They conclude that the bifurcated pattern of BSSs in NGC 2173 observed by L18 is a field contamination artefact. In this note, we explore the central concentration properties of the removed `field stars' identified by D18. Our purpose is to examine if these `field stars' are spatially homogeneously distributed. Employing a Monte Carlo-based approach, we have carefully studied the probability that any such central concentration may be caused by small number statistics. We find that, in most cases of, the `field stars' removed by D18 exhibit a clear central concentration, which cannot be explained on the basis of small number statistics alone. Therefore, we suggest that D18 may well have overestimated the field contamination level, implying that the bifurcated BSS pattern in NGC 2173 cannot, in fact, be explained by field contamination.