Comments on ""Hot" electrons in metallic nanostructures -- non-thermal carriers or heating?" and "Assistance of metal nanoparticles to photo-catalysis -- nothing more than a classical heat source"

Abstract

The authors of preprint arXiv:1810.00565 and paper in Light: Science & Applications (2019), Y. Dubi and Y. Sivan, made several wrong and inconsistent comments on several of our papers. In addition, the paper in Faraday Discuss. 214, 215-233 (2018) by the same authors also contains several wrong statements in relationship with our work. Moreover, the authors address in their comments features that were in fact not present in our work. In what follows we present correction to a number of specific points in which they either misrepresented or erroneously interpreted our published work.