Fundamental Limitations in Biomarker Based Early Disease Diagnosis

Abstract

Clinical biosensors with low detection limit hold significant promise in the early diagnosis of debilitating diseases. Recent progress in sensor development has led to the demonstration of detection capable of detecting target molecules even down to single-molecule level. One crucial performance parameter which is not adequately discussed is the issue of measurement fidelity in such sensors. We define measurement fidelity based on the false positive rate of the system as we expect systems with higher sensitivity to concomitantly respond more to interfering molecules thus increasing the false-positive rates. We present a model which allows us to estimate the limit of detection of a biosensor system constrained by a specified false-positive rate. Two major results emerging from our model is that a) there is a lower bound to the detection limit for a target molecule determined by the variation in the concentration of background molecules interfering with the molecular recognition process and b) systems which use a secondary label, such as a fluorophore, can achieve lower detection limits for a given false positive rate. We also present data collected from literature to support our model. The insights from our model will be useful in the systematic design of future clinical biosensors to achieve relevant detection limits with assured fidelity.