A note on occur-check (extended report)

Abstract

We weaken the notion of "not subject to occur-check" (NSTO), on which most known results on avoiding the occur-check in logic programming are based. NSTO means that unification is performed only on such pairs of atoms for which the occur-check never succeeds in any run of a nondeterministic unification algorithm. Here we show that "any run" can be weakened to "some run". We present some related sufficient conditions under which the occur-check may be safely omitted. We show examples for which the proposed approach provides more general results than the approaches based on well-moded and nicely moded programs (this includes cases to which the latter approaches are inapplicable). We additionally present a sufficient condition based on NSTO, working for arbitrary selection rules.