Quantum advantage through the magic pentagram problem

Abstract

Through the two specific problems, the 2D hidden linear function problem and the 1D magic square problem, Bravyi et al. have recently shown that there exists a separation between $\mathbf{QNC^0}$ and $\mathbf{NC^0}$, where $\mathbf{QNC^0}$ and $\mathbf{NC^0}$ are the classes of polynomial-size and constant-depth quantum and classical circuits with bounded fan-in gates, respectively. In this paper, we present another problem with the same property, the magic pentagram problem based on the magic pentagram game, which is a nonlocal game. In other words, we show that the problem can be solved with certainty by a $\mathbf{QNC^0}$ circuit but not by any $\mathbf{NC^0}$ circuits.