Hyperproperty Verification as CHC Satisfiability

Abstract

Hyperproperties govern the behavior of a system or systems across multiple executions, and are being recognized as an important extension of regular temporal properties. So far, such properties have resisted comprehensive treatment by modern software model-checking approaches such as IC3/PDR, due to the need to find not only an inductive invariant but also a \emph{total} alignment of different executions that facilitates simpler inductive invariants. We show how this treatment is achieved via a reduction from the verification problem of $\forall^k\exists^l$ properties to Constrained Horn Clauses. The approach is based on combining the inference of an alignment and inductive invariant in a single CHC encoding; and, for existential quantification over traces, incorporating also inference of a witness function for the existential choices, based on a game semantics with a sound-and-complete encoding to CHCs as well.