An alternative spontaneous symmetry breaking pattern for $\rm{U}(1)$ with no gapless Goldstone mode

Abstract

An emergent gapless Goldstone mode originates from continuous spontaneous symmetry breaking, which has become a doctrine since the pioneering work by Goldstone [J. Goldstone, Nuovo Cimento \textbf{19}, 154 (1961)]. However, we argue that it is possible for a continuous symmetry group $\rm{U}(1)$ to make an exceptional case, simply due to the well-known mathematical result that a continuous symmetry group $\rm{U}(1)$ may be regarded as a limit of a discrete symmetry group $Z_q$ when $q$ tends to infinity. As a consequence, spontaneous symmetry breaking for such a continuous symmetry group $\rm{U}(1)$ does not necessarily lead to any gapless Goldstone mode. This is explicitly explained for an anisotropic extension of the ferromagnetic spin-1 biquadratic model. In a sense, this model provides an illustrative example regarding the dichotomy between continuity and discreteness.