The expected value of sample information calculations for external validation of risk prediction models

Abstract

In designing external validation studies of clinical prediction models, contemporary sample size calculation methods are based on the frequentist inferential paradigm. One of the widely reported metrics of model performance is net benefit (NB), and the relevance of conventional inference around NB as a measure of clinical utility is doubtful. Value of Information methodology quantifies the consequences of uncertainty in terms of its impact on clinical utility of decisions. We introduce the expected value of sample information (EVSI) for validation as the expected gain in NB from conducting an external validation study of a given size. We propose algorithms for EVSI computation, and in a case study demonstrate how EVSI changes as a function of the amount of current information and future study's sample size. Value of Information methodology provides a decision-theoretic lens to the process of planning a validation study of a risk prediction model and can complement conventional methods when designing such studies.