Influence of Magnetic Anisotropy on the Ground State of [CH$_3$NH$_3$]Fe(HCOO)$_3$: Insights into the Improper Modulated Magnetic Structure

Abstract

The hybrid perovskites [CH$_3$NH$_3$]Co$_x$Ni$_{x-1}$(HCOO)$_3$ with $x$ = 0, 0.25, 0.5, 0.75 and 1.0 possess multiple phase transitions including incommensurate structures. [CH$_3$NH$_3$]Ni(HCOO)$_3$ has also been found to have a proper magnetic incommensurate structure in its ground state. We have carried out a detailed structural characterization of the isomorphous [CH$_3$NH$_3$]Fe(HCOO)$_3$ (1) to investigate whether it also has incommensurate structural and magnetic modulations. We confirm that 1 crystallizes in the $Pnma$ space group at room temperature (RT) with a perovskite structure. Upon cooling, at about 170 K, the occurrence of new satellite reflections in the diffraction pattern show a phase transition to a modulated structure, which could be refined in the $Pnma(00\gamma)0s0$ super space group with $q_1~=~0.1662(2)c^\ast$. On further cooling to 75 K the satellite reflections become closer to the main reflections, indicating a new phase transition that keeps the super space group invariant but changes the modulation wave vector, $q_2~=~0.1425(2)c^\ast$. The structure then does not change structural phase down to base temperature (2 K). Magnetic susceptibility measurements collected under field-cooled and zero-field-cooled reveal a 3D antiferromagnetic order below 17 K. The overlapping in temperature between structural modulation and long-range magnetic order presents a unique opportunity to study magneto-structural coupling. Our results point to an improper modulated structure where interestingly the spins oriented strictly antiferromagnetic are perpendicular to those of previously reported compounds. In the present work, a combination of magnetometry measurements, single crystal and powder neutron diffraction and density functional theory calculations have been used to accurately determine and understand the sequence of nuclear and magnetic phases present in compound 1.