Better bootstrap t confidence intervals for the mean

Abstract

This article explores combinations of weighted bootstraps, like the Bayesian bootstrap, with the bootstrap $t$ method for setting approximate confidence intervals for the mean of a random variable in small samples. For this problem the usual bootstrap $t$ has good coverage but provides intervals with long and highly variable lengths. Those intervals can have infinite length not just for tiny $n$, when the data have a discrete distribution. The BC$_a$ bootstrap produces shorter intervals but tends to severely under-cover the mean. Bootstrapping the studentized mean with weights from a Beta$(1/2,3/2)$ distribution is shown to attain second order accuracy. It never yields infinite length intervals and the mean square bootstrap $t$ statistic is finite when there are at least three distinct values in the data, or two distinct values appearing at least three times each. In a range of small sample settings, the beta bootstrap $t$ intervals have closer to nominal coverage than the BC$_a$ and shorter length than the multinomial bootstrap $t$. The paper includes a lengthy discussion of the difficulties in constructing a utility function to evaluate nonparametric approximate confidence intervals.