$\mathbb{R}^{2k}$ is Theoretically Large Enough for Embedding-based Top-$k$ Retrieval

Abstract

This paper studies the Minimal Embeddable Dimension (MED): the least dimension in which there exists a configuration of $m$ object vectors so that every subset of size at most $k$ is exactly retrieved by score comparison. Our result shows MED is $Θ(k)$, independent of $m$, for inner product, Euclidean distance, and cosine similarity. We then consider Robust MED (RMED), where all vectors are unit normed and an $ε$ gap of scores is required. We derive the $m$-dependent feasibility ceiling $ε_\star(m,k)=m/\sqrt{k(m-1)(m-k)}$, which approaches $1/\sqrt{k}$ when $m\gg k$, and a Gaussian centroid construction gives a robust witness upper bound in the feasible margin regime. Numerical simulation on synthetic top-$2$ retrieval with cyclic polytope and centroid query optimization confirmed our theoretical claims. Experiments on LIMIT and LIMIT-small datasets also show that simple embedding-based retrieval baselines can overfit and outperform the reported single-vector LLM embedding baseline. Both theoretical and empirical findings rule out the lack of exact geometric capacity as the obstruction.