Planar Graph Homomorphisms: A Dichotomy and a Barrier from Quantum Groups

Abstract

We study the complexity of counting (weighted) planar graph homomorphism problem $\tt{Pl\text{-}GH}(M)$ parametrized by an arbitrary symmetric non-negative real valued matrix $M$. For matrices with pairwise distinct diagonal values, we prove a complete dichotomy theorem: $\tt{Pl\text{-}GH}(M)$ is either polynomial-time tractable, or $\#$P-hard, according to a simple criterion. More generally, we obtain a dichotomy whenever every vertex pair of the graph represented by $M$ can be separated using some planar edge gadget. A key question in proving complexity dichotomies in the planar setting is the expressive power of planar edge gadgets. We build on the framework of Man\v{c}inska and Roberson to establish links between \textit{planar} edge gadgets and the theory of the \textit{quantum automorphism group} $\tt{Qut}(M)$. We show that planar edge gadgets that can separate vertex pairs of $M$ exist precisely when $\tt{Qut}(M)$ is \emph{trivial}, and prove that the problem of whether $\tt{Qut}(M)$ is trivial is undecidable. These results delineate the frontier for planar homomorphism counting problems and uncover intrinsic barriers to extending nonplanar reduction techniques to the planar setting.