SCARV: Structure-Constrained Aggregation for Stable Sample Ranking in Redundant NLP Datasets

Abstract

Sample-level rankings are increasingly used in data-centric NLP for analysis, filtering, debugging, and curation, yet existing pipelines typically score training examples pointwise and rank them as if they were independent. This assumption is fragile in the presence of exact duplicates, near-duplicates, paraphrases, and other redundant structure common in NLP corpora, where stochastic training can make highly similar examples receive unstable relative orderings across random seeds. We study stable sample-level ranking under redundancy and propose \textsc{SCARV}, a modular aggregation framework that operates on top of an existing scoring proxy. \textsc{SCARV} combines robust multi-seed aggregation with a structure-aware aggregation/allocation step over redundancy clusters. Across synthetic redundancy, naturally mined QQP redundancy, multiple proxy families, several NLP tasks, and end-to-end DistilBERT fine-tuning, \textsc{SCARV} substantially improves over bare proxy rankings in global and local stability and yields more reproducible ranking-based decisions such as subset selection and suspicious-example retrieval. Our decomposition and compute-aware frontier sharpen the mechanism: robust multi-seed aggregation is the dominant generic stabilizer, while the structure-aware component adds value mainly under low aggregation budgets or when redundancy clusters are informative, naturally occurring, or sufficiently covered. These results position \textsc{SCARV} not as a universal data selector or a universally dominant replacement for seed-only aggregation, but as a stability-oriented aggregation layer for proxy-induced rankings in redundant NLP datasets.