Indefinite Causal Order Reverses the Real-Complex Hierarchy

Abstract

[Note added after submission. After posting the first version of this preprint and corresponding with Ved Kunte and Kuntal Sengupta, we identified an issue with the claimed separation between real quantum theory and ordinary complex quantum theory in the process-matrix framework. This version imposes normalization only for local CPTP maps acting on the parties' process input-output systems, which we call N1. A stronger compositional requirement is to impose normalization also after arbitrary shared ancillary systems are introduced and each party acts jointly on its process system and local share of the ancilla, which we call N2. Under N2, the process matrix used in this version to separate RQT from QT is not valid, and the claimed RQT/QT separation is therefore not established. We are preparing a revised version that clarifies this distinction and revises the affected claims. This temporary update is intended to alert readers to this issue while we work on revising the manuscript.]