Classical versus quantum Anderson localization in disordered systems

Abstract

We investigate Anderson localization in three-dimensional disordered systems by comparing scalar classical waves with mass and force-constant disorder to electronic tight-binding models with diagonal and off-diagonal disorder. We show that the commonly employed mapping between classical-wave localization and the electronic Anderson model with diagonal disorder is not mathematically justified. Instead, the correct modulus-type formulation reveals that classical-wave systems constitute a distinct constrained disorder class, in which the acoustic sum rule correlates diagonal and off-diagonal matrix elements and prevents any direct correspondence with the standard electronic disorder models. Within a unified eigenvalue framework, we determine localization phase diagrams for all four disorder classes using complementary spectral, eigenvector, and level-statistics diagnostics. We find that classical-wave systems share a key qualitative feature with electronic off-diagonal disorder: localized states occur only near a band edge, while extended states persist in the central part of the spectrum even at strong disorder. At the same time, the acoustic sum rule produces localization topologies that differ fundamentally from both diagonal- and off-diagonal-disorder electronic systems. In particular, for mass disorder we obtain a phase diagram that differs qualitatively from previous results based on the conventional potential-type approach and reveals an extended localized regime near the upper band edge. Our results establish a unified perspective on localization in quantum and classical wave systems and provide new insight into the conditions under which Anderson localization may occur in three-dimensional photonic and acoustic media.