Granular Instrumental Variables in Large Panels: Identification and Inference Across Strong, Nearly Weak, and Weak GIV

Abstract

I develop the asymptotic theory of instrument strength for Granular Instrumental Variables (GIV) in large panels with both $N$ and $T$ growing. The strength of the GIV depends on the presence of dominant units. I formalise what dominance means and characterise three regimes of instrument strength. When a few units dominate the aggregate, the instrument is strong. The GIV estimator is consistent and asymptotically normal at the standard $\sqrt{T}$ rate. When large units stand out but do not dominate, the instrument weakens. But I show that the parameter of interest remains recoverable. The GIV estimator remains consistent and asymptotically normal, now at a rate slower than $\sqrt{T}$. When units are comparable in size and none stands out, the instrument is weak in the standard sense. The GIV estimator is inconsistent and has a non-standard distribution. Wald inference is reliable only outside the weak regime. When the instrument is weak, I recommend Anderson-Rubin confidence sets. In practice, the instrument must be constructed in a first stage. I show that the feasible estimator attains the same rate, but its asymptotic variance picks up an additional term from the first-stage estimation. Valid inference must use standard errors that account for this term. I apply the GIV estimator with the correct standard errors to recover the short-run demand elasticities of three commodities: refined copper, crude oil, and natural gas.