The arrival position problem in quantum mechanics

Abstract

The problem of making unambiguous probabilistic predictions about experiments involving waiting "always on" detectors remains a challenge for quantum theory. While most research on this problem studies arrival time, i.e., predicting the distribution of when detection events occur, this paper studies the arrival position problem, which is the complementary challenge of predicting the distribution of where detection events occur. Despite the widespread recognition of the arrival time problem, the inability of standard quantum theory to address the arrival position problem remains a pervasive theoretical blind spot. In this paper, we compare quantitative arrival position predictions derived from prominent proposed solutions to the screen problem. As we show, these models yield distinguishable predictions even in relatively simple experiments achievable with current technology. Notably, many of these discrepancies persist even in the far-field limit, where standard semiclassical approximations are typically assumed to be valid.