When one sign is not enough: 2+1 circular motion Unruh effect at low energies

Abstract

We address the circular motion Unruh effect in 2+1 spacetime dimensions, as probed by a pointlike Unruh-DeWitt detector coupled to a massless scalar field. The effective temperature due to circular acceleration, operationally defined in terms of the detector's excitation and de-excitation probabilities, is known to be much smaller than the linear acceleration Unruh temperature when the detector's energy gap is small and the interaction lasts for a long time. It was shown by Parry et al. [Class. Quant. Grav. 42, 245012 (2025), arXiv:2508.19987] that a temperature of the order of the linear acceleration Unruh temperature can nevertheless be recovered in a simultaneous long-time-small-gap double limit, using suitable classes of detector-field couplings described by asymptotically scaled switching families (ASSFs). The successful constructions presented there required the coupling to change sign. Here we prove, within the ASSF framework and under certain technical boundedness and localisation conditions, that sign changes in the detector-field coupling are in fact *necessary* for obtaining a nonvanishing limiting effective temperature. Our analysis is motivated by current work towards an experimental verification of the circular motion Unruh effect in analogue spacetime experiments.