Challenges in probing turbulent and magnetic support in cores: the W43-MM1 protocluster case study

Abstract

Estimating the level of non-thermal support in cores is both challenging and crucial for constraining the earliest stages of star formation. We quantify the kinetic and magnetic support operating within the cores of the high-mass protocluster W43-MM1, and test the assumptions behind the virial theorem used to interpret observations. We used ALMA 12m molecular line observations of DCN (3-2), 13CS (5-4), and CH3CN (5_3-4_3) to estimate kinetic support. The plane-of-sky magnetic field strength (B_POS) was derived from dust-polarization observations using the Davis-Chandrasekhar-Fermi method, obtained at the three-beam scale (~12500 au) and extrapolated to core scales (~2500 au) using the density-field strength relation. We derive kinetic support estimates for 45 cores (21 prestellar and 24 protostellar), of which 21 also have magnetic field estimates. Velocity dispersions range from 0.34 to 4.48 km/s, and B_POS values span 1.1-49.3 mG at core scales. Using the virial theorem, ~70% of cores appear stable against collapse when considering turbulence alone, and ~85% when combining both kinetic and magnetic support (alpha_vir,B > 1). These are unexpectedly high values, particularly for protostellar cores expected to be undergoing collapse. We conclude that contamination of linewidths by organized motions (1-3 km/s, consistent with previous observational studies), together with the omission of surface terms in the observational virial theorem, prevents accurate measurement of non-thermal support in cores. This highlights that simplified virial analyses can introduce significant biases when assessing physical support mechanisms within cores.