Comment on "Scaling of the linear response in simple aging systems without disorder"

Abstract

We have repeated the simulations of Henkel, Paessens and Pleimling (HPP) [Phys.Rev.E {\bf 69}, 056109 (2004)] for the field-cooled susceptibility $\chi_{FC}(t) - \chi_0 \sim t^{-A}$ in the quench of ferromagnetic systems to and below $T_C$. We show that, contrary to the statement made by HPP, the exponent $A$ coincides with the exponent $a$ of the linear response function $R(t,s) \sim s^{-(1+a)}f_R(t/s)$. We point out what are the assumptions in the argument of HPP that lead them to the conclusion $A<a$.