From bcc to fcc: interplay between oscillating long-range and repulsive short-range forces

Abstract

This paper supplements and partly extends an earlier publication, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 265501 (2005). In $d$-dimensional continuous space we describe the infinite volume ground state configurations (GSCs) of pair interactions $\vfi$ and $\vfi+\psi$, where $\vfi$ is the inverse Fourier transform of a nonnegative function vanishing outside the sphere of radius $K_0$, and $\psi$ is any nonnegative finite-range interaction of range $r_0\leq\gamma_d/K_0$, where $\gamma_3=\sqrt{6}\pi$. In three dimensions the decay of $\vfi$ can be as slow as $\sim r^{-2}$, and an interaction of asymptotic form $\sim\cos(K_0r+\pi/2)/r^3$ is among the examples. At a dimension-dependent density $\rho_d$ the ground state of $\vfi$ is a unique Bravais lattice, and for higher densities it is continuously degenerate: any union of Bravais lattices whose reciprocal lattice vectors are not shorter than $K_0$ is a GSC. Adding $\psi$ decreases the ground state degeneracy which, nonetheless, remains continuous in the open interval $(\rho_d,\rho_d')$, where $\rho_d'$ is the close-packing density of hard balls of diameter $r_0$. The ground state is unique at both ends of the interval. In three dimensions this unique GSC is the bcc lattice at $\rho_3$ and the fcc lattice at $\rho_3'=\sqrt{2}/r_0^3$.