Description of Double Giant Dipole Resonance within the Phonon Damping Model

Abstract

In a recent Letter [1] an overall agreement with the experimental data for the excitation of the single and double giant dipole resonances in relativistic heavy ion collision in 136Xe and 208Pb nuclei has been reported. We point out that this agreement is achieved by a wrong calculation of the DGDR excitation mechanism. We also argue that the agreement with the data for the widths of resonances is achieved by an unrealistically large value of a model parameter. [1] Nguyen Dinh Dang, Vuong Kim Au, and Akito Arima, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85 (2000) 1827.