On the detection of absolute velocity in a Newtonian universe
Jorge Manero, Ricardo Muciño, Elias Okon
Abstract
As a fundamental arena for the development of his dynamics, Newton postulated the existence of absolute space, in which bodies innately possess absolute velocity. Despite this, Newton argued that, although real, absolute properties cannot be detected. Since then, the claim that absolute velocity would be undetectable in such a Newtonian universe has been generally accepted. Here, we show that standard arguments for such a claim, beginning with the one offered by Newton himself, beg the question. We conclude that there are no formal reasons to believe that absolute velocity would be undetectable in a Newtonian universe.
Create a lesson
Related papers
The Bomb, the Hubris, and the Spectre
Alberto Girlando
Holography as an Information Principle in Quantum Gravity
Sebastian De Haro, Enrico Cinti, Aude Corbeel
Dark Matters of Principle: Principles in the Dark Matter Paradigm
Patrick Duerr, James Read
Does the Actuality of Life Favor Many Actual Histories?
Jonathan Baxter
Minkowski's Geometric Explanation of Lorentz Contraction
Tilman Sauer
The comets discovered from New Zealand, and the astronomers who found them
John Drummond, Wayne Orchiston, Carolyn Brown et al.