Wading the String Bog: CMB Birefringence in the Swampland

Abstract

We point out that observations of cosmic birefringence may provide direct experimental tests of Swampland conjectures. Ultralight scalar field birefringence mechanisms are constrained by Weak Gravity Conjecture, limiting their parameter space. Conversely, confirming that CMB birefringence is caused by ultralight scalars could spell problems for the Swampland framework. Resolving these difficulties without a revision of Swampland ideology points toward thin axionic domain walls, which can explain birefringence without propagating ultralight degrees of freedom. Importantly these conflicting scenarios for cosmic birefringence could be experimentally distinguished by a search for, or exclusion of, birefringence anisotropies, that could be measured by POLARBEAR, Simons Observatory and LiteBIRD. We also note that cosmic birefringence observables emerge via a Sakharov-like asymmetry, where linear polarization is first generated cosmologically and subsequently twisted by a parity-violating dynamics after last scattering.