Laminar gaps mirror turbulent puffs in pipe flow

Abstract

Pipe flow at intermediate Reynolds numbers, between the laminar and fully turbulent regimes, takes the form of several spatially and temporally intermittent phases in which turbulent and laminar states coexist. In the lower range, $Re\in (1750,2300)$, turbulence appears in the form of localized traveling structures called "puffs", which form long-lived chaotic dynamical states, whose stochastic decays and splits control the steady state intermittency. At the other end, $Re\in (2300,3000)$, puffs are replaced by an extended turbulent state, with laminar pockets intermittently forming and disappearing within it. Using direct numerical simulations of pipe flow at $Re = 2400, 2450, 2500, 2550$, we provide evidence that these laminar gaps form a distinct dynamical state analogous to puffs: a traveling laminar pocket in a turbulent surrounding, stabilized by a shear-dependent self-tuning mechanism. We analyse the mean spatial profile of these gaps and show that their lifetimes are exponentially distributed, suggesting that gap closing corresponds to an escape from a chaotic saddle. Finally, we suggest these laminar gaps become unstable and disappear at a finite Reynolds number, $Re\sim 2900$, which can be interpreted as the onset point of spatially and temporally homogeneous turbulence.