Topological defects in reflection positive topological field theories

Abstract

Topological defects in quantum field theories are believed to assemble into higher categories with extra structure. This has been made precise for defects in $2$- and $3$-dimensional oriented topological quantum field theories by Davydov, Kong, and Runkel and by Carqueville, Meusburger, and Schaumann, respectively. In this paper we study the extra structure present on these categories when the topological field theory is additionally reflection positive. We define reflection defect TQFTs as symmetric monoidal functors out of a defect bordism category that intertwine orientation reversal with complex conjugation; they are reflection positive if they satisfy an additional positivity condition. Our main result is that in two dimensions the bicategory of defects $\mathcal{T}_\mathcal{Z}$ associated to a reflection defect TQFT carries the natural structure of an $O(2)$-dagger bicategory, a structure we define explicitly. If the theory is reflection positive, $\mathcal{T}_\mathcal{Z}$ can be equipped with additional structure closely related to the definition of a 3-Hilbert space (the two agree up to some finiteness and completeness conditions).