A contiguity approach to replica symmetric marginals

Abstract

We develop a probabilistic cavity-contiguity framework for proving replica-symmetric convergence of local marginals in mean-field Gibbs systems. The approach is based on cavity decompositions of the Hamiltonian together with direct comparison of probability measures through Radon-Nikodym derivatives and Hellinger-type estimates. At a conceptual level, the method separates the concentration of the relevant order parameters from the identification of the asymptotic cavity model and the comparison of the associated Gibbs measures. In contrast with interpolation-based approaches, the argument relies only weakly on the Gaussianity of the disorder and naturally accommodates concentration tools such as Poincaré and log-Sobolev inequalities. Rather than pursuing maximal generality, with the aim of making the method transparent, we implement the framework in a canonical example: the high-temperature Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model. In this setting, we prove that the marginal law of a fixed spin converges in total variation toward the effective one-dimensional cavity measure predicted by the replica method. Beyond the specific result for the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model, the paper illustrates a broader cavity-contiguity methodology which is expected to extend naturally to other mean-field Gibbs systems, particularly Bayesian inference models with or without mismatch.