Supernovae Ia ejecta velocities and host galaxy environments: the role of survey-selection effects

Abstract

The origin of the near-maximum-light Si II $λ$6355 velocity diversity among supernovae Ia (SNe Ia) remains uncertain. Previous studies have suggested that high-velocity (HV) and normal-velocity (NV) SNe Ia occupy systematically different host galaxy environments, implying differences in their progenitor populations. We re-examine this hypothesis using a sample of 354 nearby ($z\leq0.04$) spectroscopically normal SNe Ia, comprising 239 NV and 115 HV events, identified in targeted and untargeted surveys. For each SN, we determine the host galaxy morphology, galactocentric distance, and physical size, and obtain homogeneous stellar mass estimates while assessing the influence of survey-selection effects. The Si II velocity distribution is well described by two Gaussian components, confirming the NV and HV populations. We find no statistically significant differences between the galactocentric distance, host galaxy size, or stellar mass distributions of the two velocity subgroups. The environmental trends reported in previous studies are recovered only with marginal statistical significance in the targeted subsample, whereas they disappear almost entirely in the untargeted subsample, consistent with survey-selection effects playing a major role in the previously inferred environmental differences between the NV and HV events. Our results weaken the interpretation that the observed Si II velocity diversity is primarily driven by systematic differences in the global host properties examined here. Instead, they favour a scenario in which intrinsic explosion asymmetries and viewing-angle effects account for a substantial fraction of the observed velocity diversity, without excluding a possible contribution from local environmental conditions or progenitor properties.