SMUDGes Below the Surface: Clusters Confirm the Diversity of Low-Surface-Brightness Galaxies

Abstract

We use spatially resolved Keck Cosmic Web Imager spectroscopy to study high-surface-brightness stellar components and internal kinematics in 44 low-surface-brightness galaxies from the SMUDGes survey, including 30 ultradiffuse galaxies, spanning the red sequence, green valley, and blue cloud regions of the galaxy color-magnitude diagram. Although these galaxies appear largely smooth in survey imaging, we detect at least one cluster candidate in every galaxy. We identify clusters with nebular emission lines in 24 galaxies. They are common in blue-cloud galaxies but rare in red sequence galaxies. We identify three nuclear star cluster candidates, one of which shows nebular emission lines. Among clusters without nebular emission lines, bluer galaxies tend to have brighter cluster luminosity functions, suggesting the presence of young or intermediate-age clusters in addition to old globular clusters. This age diversity may complicate the use of photometrically selected globular cluster populations as tracers of total halo mass. We measure rotation velocities for 17 galaxies using the clusters with nebular emission lines and for 12 using diffuse stellar light. Within 0.5 effective radii, the inferred dynamical mass generally exceeds the stellar mass, although the inferred dark matter contribution varies by an order of magnitude. The variety in properties for this sample of ultradiffuse galaxies and low-surface-brightness dwarfs suggests that no single formation mechanism explains the population of low-surface-brightness galaxies.