Multilevel modelling of double-sampled clustered social networks with individual-level data on between-cluster ties

Abstract

We consider the analysis of dyadic network data on ties between individuals in different clusters where the presence of a directed tie is reported by each individual in a dyad and the cluster-level network is of interest. A generalisation of the Social Relations Model (SRM) is proposed which includes actor, partner and dyad effects at the individual and cluster levels. The model additionally uses ``double-sampling'' of ties to estimate a measurement model which adjusts for and quantifies the extent of reporter effects. The model can be viewed as a type of multilevel structural equation model, with multiple cross-classified random effects, which can be estimated using Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods in Bayesian software. Using parameter estimates from this multilevel SRM, we then propose two alternative ways of deriving the between-cluster network that are based on predictions of the strength of between-cluster ties. Our approach is illustrated using data on social support networks in a rural community in Nicaragua where individual reports of bidirectional exchanges of support with individuals from other households are used to derive the between-household network.