The Iterative Conception Reconsidered

Abstract

We investigate the iterative conception of set in its most general form, allowing urelements without assuming that they form a set. We formulate this conception in two ways, as stage theory and as level theory, and develop a general theory of levels with urelements. Unlike their pure-set counterparts, the resulting stage and level theories are not set-theoretically equivalent; moreover, second-order level theory with urelements is not weakly quasi-categorical. We then consider further principles governing stages and levels, motivated by directedness, unboundedness, and reflection. Some of these principles restore set-theoretic equivalence between the corresponding theories, while their level-theoretic versions yield forms of quasi-categoricity. These principles form strict implication hierarchies, thereby revealing distinct stronger conceptions of set beyond the basic iterative conception.