Big Bang For Your Helium Buck

Abstract

We study the implications of a recent measurement of the primordial helium fraction from the Large Binocular Telescope for cosmological inference from the cosmic microwave background. We show that LBT establishes the robustness of cosmological parameters to theoretical assumptions about big bang nucleosynthesis: its empirical calibration of the helium fraction enables constraints on cosmology and inflation that are agnostic to BBN but as precise as those that instead enforce standard BBN predictions. Future CMB surveys require at most a marginal improvement in precision over LBT to maximize their BBN-agnostic constraining power when the radiation density is free (and no more than a factor of two improvement across all cases we consider). We then apply the LBT measurement to a number of scenarios that feature new physics in BBN and the CMB. First, we constrain nonstandard radiation sectors (interacting and free-streaming) and search for evolution of the radiation abundance between nucleosynthesis and recombination. We then test models that alleviate the Hubble tension and the tension between CMB and baryon acoustic oscillation data, including self-interacting light relics and varying fundamental constants; LBT precludes most but not all of the models we consider via their effect on BBN. Finally, we use the LBT measurement as an indirect but independent test of the neutron lifetime anomaly, inferring values that are consistent with "bottle" experiments and $2.4 σ$ below "beam" experiments.