On the Expressive Power of Implicit Line-Graph Higher-Order Weisfeiler--Leman

Abstract

Whitney's theorem allows isomorphism testing for connected simple graphs, apart from $K_3$ and $K_{1,3}$, to be formulated as distinguishing their line graphs. However, the relation between fixed-dimensional Weisfeiler--Leman (WL) expressivity on line graphs and on their roots remains unresolved. We study this relation through Implicit Line-Graph WL (ILG-$k$-WL), which is exactly $k$-WL on $L(G)$, executed over the edges of $G$ with line-graph relations derived from endpoint incidence and without explicitly constructing $L(G)$. On the Whitney-general class, the relation between root-domain and line-graph WL depends on $k$. For $k=1,2$, ILG-$k$-WL adds no distinguishing power beyond root-domain $1$-WL and misses some pairs that $1$-WL separates. For $k=3$, we prove the backward containment $L(G)\equiv_{3\text{-WL}}L(H)\Rightarrow G\equiv_{3\text{-WL}}H$. Strongly regular witness pairs, including the Shrikhande/rook pair, show that ILG-$3$-WL is strictly more expressive than $3$-WL. The backward containment also extends to disconnected graphs with no isolated vertices when every connected component is Whitney-general. Deterministic ILG-$3$-WL separates all three substructure-counting witness pairs, all $105$ pairs in SR25, and $359$ of $400$ BREC pairs. An untrained dense ILG-$3$-GNN gives the same pairwise verdicts on these evaluations.