Reply to "Comment on 'Topography of Fermi arcs in t-PtBi2 using high-resolution angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy'"
Adam Kaminski, Paul C. Canfield, Benjamin Schrunk
Abstract
In a recent work [1] we demonstrated that the Fermi arcs in t-PtBi2 are indeed disconnected segments of the Fermi surface. We showed that the surface state band crosses EF between Weyl points and is has finite band gap at all other momenta until it merges with bulk bands. We did not find evidence of a superconducting gap in the spectra down to 3K. In recent Comment, Sergey Borisenko reanalyzed data from repository posted with our paper and concluded that a superconducting gap with i-wave symmetry is present in our data up to temperatures of 19K. We argue that this claim arises from incorrect identification of the location of Fermi arc and confusion between band gap and superconducting gap. This error was compounded by the fact that Author of the Comment analyzed data from interpolated images used for mapping the Fermi surface that are not suitable for extraction of energy gap on meV scale. This fact was previously communicated to the Author of the Comment during e-mail exchange. We maintain that our conclusion of absence of a superconducting gap above 3 K are valid and consistent with recent STM measurements performed on the same samples, which found surface superconductivity with Tc = 3K, below the temperature at which the data for our ARPES paper was measured.
Create a lesson
Related papers
Comparative First-Principles Study of the Physical Properties, Phonon-Mediated Superconductivity and Functional Potential of Technetium-Based Binary Borides TcB2, Tc2B and Tc3B
M. Rabi Us Sani Shapon, Jubair Hossan Abir, Md. Asif Afzal et al.
Generalized Critical-State Analysis of Local Field Screening in High-Pressure Yttrium Polyhydride
A. G. Gavriliuk, I. A. Troyan, A. A. Mironovich et al.
Magnetic order in Tb and Dy substituted La3Ni2O7 and effects of high-pressure high-temperature O2 annealing
Yuhang Deng, Farhad Taraporevala, Jui-Chia Lee et al.
First order vortex-unbinding transition in 2D topological superconductors
Vera Mikheeva, Elio J. König
Umklapp-enhanced high-Tc topological superconductivity mediated by magnons in p-wave magnets
Kristoffer Leraand, Asle Sudbø
Reconciling Models for Infinite-Layer Nickelate Superconductors: Role of Interstitial-s Band or A-Pocket
Ao Zhang, Chao Deng, Leonard M. Verhoff et al.