Taste or Strategy? Nationalistic Bias and Competitor Penalties in Figure Skating Judging
Jialin Liu, Shu Shen
Abstract
Many decisions rest on expert panels whose members have ties to some candidates, and favoritism is hard to tell from shared taste or better information. Using a rich dataset from figure skating, we find evidence of a strategic compatriot premium and a targeted penalty on the compatriot's close rivals. The premium falls along a randomly drawn start order and, before 2022/23, rises when close rivals have their own judges on the panel. The penalty grows with the compatriot's placement chances and fades once she is out of contention. A counterfactual analysis shows that these biases can shape close competitions.
Create a lesson
Related papers
Structural economic change under the digital transformation
Marco Dueñas, Antoine Mandel
Globally promoting legumes by production or use subsidies
Pablo de la Vega, Wolfgang Britz
Persistence and Change in National Production Networks
Haojie Liu, Zihan Lin
AI, Specialization, and the Organization of Knowledge Work: Evidence from Legal Services
Liu Zhang, Mark Esposito, Isabel Yang
Does the AI Reviewer Alleviate or Aggravate the Maintenance Burden? Evidence from GitHub Copilot Reviewer
Feiyang, Xu, Poonacha K. Medappa et al.
Clicks, Carbon, and Risk: Climate Attention, Persistent Financial Risk, and Real-Sector Activity
Giovanni Angelini, Luca De Angelis