Measuring Definition Sensitivity in LLM Annotation of Social Science Concepts
Bogdan Mamaev, Qizhou Wang, Christopher Leckie, Matteo Vergani
Abstract
In social science research, text annotation is a fundamental task that is traditionally a costly, hard-to-scale manual process. Researchers have used large language models (LLMs) to perform annotation by writing a definition of a concept into a prompt - a rule that determines whether a label should be attributed to a text depending on its content. However, concepts such as hate speech, fake news, and terrorism typically have several theoretically defensible competing definitions. It is also unknown whether the model actually applied the definition to provide the label or the label was based on the model's pretrained notion of the concept. To test this, we have the model annotate the same texts twice, each time with a different definition. We call the disagreement between the two sets of annotations definition sensitivity. As a control, we paraphrase one definition but leave its requirements unchanged - the disagreement between the annotations with the two wordings becomes the paraphrase floor. Across six concepts and three LLMs, a swap of competing definitions always changes more annotations, on average, than a paraphrase. This shows that the annotations depend on the prompted definition, so any set of annotations should be interpreted together with the definition that produced it. The LLM annotator's definition sensitivity and its paraphrase floor should both be reported in such work.
Create a lesson
Related papers
Represented but misread: Post-training changes how language models read out what they represent
Jochen Laubrock
AutoMaster: Autonomous Post-Training by Making the Same Model a Better Teacher
Guoxin Chen, Shuang Sun, Fanzhe Meng et al.
Multimodal Error Detection in Chest X-ray Reports: A Large Language Model Reading Image Evidence
Yanda Cheng, Bo Wen, Yuhao Lu
MemFolder: Structure-Guided Memory Folding for Efficient Agent Memory Management
Xuyang Liu, Chenwen Lu, Junxi Wang et al.
Beam Model Technical Report
Reflection Team, Adam Abdulhamid, Osama Abuelsorour et al.
One Framework to Diagnose Them All: A Stratified Benchmark for Bengali LLM Hallucination
Asif Shahriyar Sushmit, Shefayat E Shams Adib, Abdullah Al Jubaer Gem et al.