Living constitutions: Participatory alignment for sovereign foundation models
Stine Lyngsø Beltoft, Jonas Vistrup, Peter Schneider-Kamp, Lukas Galke Poech
Abstract
In Constitutional AI, a plain-text "constitution" encodes values and gets incorporated into a model via post-training. However, the procedure for creating such a constitution poses significant challenges: who contributes, who decides which norms are included, and to what extent must the process be participatory or democratic? These challenges can be paralyzing. Yet, we argue that taking action is essential: without a deliberate constitution, sovereign models would risk misalignment or default to norms set by frontier model providers. We propose treating the development of a constitution as an evolving, participatory process akin to citizen science, iteratively drafted, tested, and refined. We therefore formulate five desirable principles: iterative, modular, justifiable, positional, and legitimate. We further argue that such a document must remain responsive not only over time but across the people it governs, and propose that provisions be marked as settled, contested, or underdetermined, so that durable disagreement is recorded in the constitution rather than resolved away. Empirically, we show via agent-based modelling that proposed process for maintaining living constitutions is robust against 50% bad actors among citizens - assuming a share of 75% participants with good intent in the deliberative body. This indicates that the proposed process tolerates a substantial share of adversarial participants.
Create a lesson
Related papers
PlayCraft: Designing Engaging Games from Agent Play Experience
Weihao Cheng
Probing the "Conscious" Mind: Selective Access and Global Workspace in Vision-Language Models
Jiahao Huang, Jun Wang
ProtoDiffusion: Token-per-Layer Generative Modeling of Multi-Layer Images
Adrià Ciurana Lanau, Harleen Hanspal, Lusine Abrahamyan et al.
MM-SystemOneBias: Evaluating Bias in Multimodal Jev-Style System One Decision Models
Jinzhe Li, Qi Wang, Dandan Guo et al.
The Geometry of Lies: Knowledge and Persona Directions for Detecting Deception in Large Language Models
Md. Abdullah Al Zami, Suraiya Shanaz, Mahdi Hasan et al.
LLM GerryMandering: Separating Interactions from Additive Effects in LLM Audits
George Rahul, Ronit Jahilal, Bhaskara Hanuma Vedula et al.