AI and the Two Margins of Work: Why Job Losses Show Up Before Job Creation
Mark Esposito, Liu Zhang
Abstract
Technological change acts on labor demand at two margins: adjustment within established activities and the creation of additional activities, often by new firms. Payroll statistics record the first promptly and the second late. In the computing era, firms that entered in 1978 or later held 42 percent of payroll by 1998 and entering cohorts kept about 80 percent of their payroll after five years; in the industries most exposed to automation, incumbents contracted before entrants accumulated, a sequence that is precise early in the period and suggestive by its end. We develop a model in which one AI capability lowers the full cost of acceptable output in existing production and makes additional projects worth attempting, with founder effort separate from hired hours. If operating products re-scale instantly, automation displaces no aggregate hours; if they take time, hours fall first and recover as incumbents re-expand and new products arrive, with the long-run sign set by income effects. Establishment job flows through the first quarter of 2026 show no gradient on language-model exposure on either margin, which is what the model predicts under the observed adoption path and also what no effect on payroll would look like; studies with founding-task exposure find entry rising 10 to 20 percent. We propose a net reinstatement ratio and show that statistics which record new work late overstate displacement for years.
Create a lesson
Related papers
Structural economic change under the digital transformation
Marco Dueñas, Antoine Mandel
Globally promoting legumes by production or use subsidies
Pablo de la Vega, Wolfgang Britz
Persistence and Change in National Production Networks
Haojie Liu, Zihan Lin
AI, Specialization, and the Organization of Knowledge Work: Evidence from Legal Services
Liu Zhang, Mark Esposito, Isabel Yang
Does the AI Reviewer Alleviate or Aggravate the Maintenance Burden? Evidence from GitHub Copilot Reviewer
Feiyang, Xu, Poonacha K. Medappa et al.
Clicks, Carbon, and Risk: Climate Attention, Persistent Financial Risk, and Real-Sector Activity
Giovanni Angelini, Luca De Angelis