Longitudinal Multi-Dimensional Analysis of India-Pakistan Conflict Discourse on Reddit (2019-2025)
Yash Khare, Hunjun Shin, Mohit Singhal
Abstract
Six India--Pakistan crises between 2019 and 2025, from the Pulwama attack to Operation Sindoor, have each been argued out on Reddit in India-aligned communities such as r/india, in Pakistan-aligned communities such as r/pakistan, and in general-audience ones such as r/worldnews. A strike can be a security issue in one community and a question of who was harmed in another. Computational studies of the conflict have concentrated on the February 2019 crisis, with some splitting posts by national side, but to the best of our knowledge none has compared how differently aligned communities frame a series of crises. To investigate this, we collected 43K posts from ten such communities on Reddit and, after filtering, used a mixed-methods approach to analyze the 305K comments under the relevant posts. We label each comment's narrative frame with GPT-5.2 and measure contestation with Reddit's flag for comments that draw many votes in both directions. Contestation rates differ 2.5-fold between general-audience and India-aligned communities and 1.8-fold between humanitarian and economic framing, but only 1.1-fold between comments that Perspective scores as toxic and the rest. The mix of frames and sentiment tracks the kind of crisis more closely than its year: the first and last crises, both military and six years apart, draw nearly identical mixes, and the 2019 revocation of Article 370 draws a different one. Crossing into another group of communities sharpens opposition rather than softening it: commenters who post both inside and outside their usual group oppose the other side more often outside it, even as slightly fewer of their comments attack a person or group.
Create a lesson
Related papers
"I Don't Think It's a Scam": A First Look at Family Intervention Barriers in Elder Abuse Discussions on Reddit and Baidu Tieba
Yipeng Wang, Huy Gia Han Vu, Jiaming Liu et al.
Dessins d'Enfants as a Topological Lens on Temporal Hypergraphs
Mehmet Emin Aktas, Esra Akbas
A comparative exploration of Steinerberger curvature and resistance curvature in model and real-world complex networks
Madhumita Mondal, Priyank Vasu, Areejit Samal et al.
Finding Patient Zero in Temporal Contact Networks: A Comparative Study
Nathan Cincera Brack, Martin Sterchi, Lorenz Hilfiker et al.
Inferring Locations and Correcting Bias in Infectious Disease Data Using Human Mobility
Owen Tucker, Lily Wang, Ruochen Kong et al.
High-Coverage Blind Spots in Online Abuse Monitoring: Account Selection, Held-Out Flagging Rates, and Sample Composition
Ziming Liu