Uncontrolled source titles: When Nature, Science, and PNAS meet Scopus
Weishu Liu, Ruifeng Zhang, Haifeng Wang
Abstract
Bibliographic databases such as Scopus and Web of Science play a critical role in literature discovery, systematic reviews, bibliometric analyses, and research evaluation, yet their reliability depends on effective control of the quality of the bibliographic data. This study examines the problem of uncontrolled source titles in Scopus by comparing five possibly adopted journal-level retrieval strategies across three flagship journals-Nature, Science, and PNAS. Substantial discrepancies across retrieval results indicate persistent fragmentation in the source title field. A comparative analysis using the Web of Science Core Collection shows that no comparable degree of uncontrolled source-title variation is observed for the same journals. The study further explores possible mechanisms, including inheritance of different title forms from (different) upstream providers, automated parsing and OCR-related artifacts, and insufficient cross-validation. Based on these findings, the study proposes recommendations at both the user and database-provider levels to improve source-title normalization and strengthen source-level metadata governance, with implications for the accuracy and reproducibility of journal-level retrieval and evaluative uses.
Create a lesson
Related papers
Do Network Mechanisms in Science Vary Across Research Topics? Contextual Relational Hyperevent Models for Large-Scale Bibliometric Data
Jürgen Lerner, Mark Wittek, Raphael Heiberger
Extracting Value from Grey Literature: processes and technologies for aggregating and analyzing the hidden big data treasure of organizations
G. Motta, R. Puccinelli, L. Reggiani et al.
Theses by publication in Spain: output, authorship and integrity concerns
Álvaro Cabezas-Clavijo, Nazaret Barriga, Rafael Repiso
Where Do Highly Cited Scientists Stand? A Multi-Dimensional Analysis of Positional Distribution in the Top 2% Ranking
Yuehai Li, Zuguang Gu
Assessing the Reliability of Longitudinal Bibliometric Rankings under Incomplete Citation Histories
João Paulo Papa
Earlier citation practices are linked to signs of artificial intelligence use in scientific writing
Hongkan Chen, Yongyuan He, Qingshan Zhou et al.