On the feasibility of using [Eu/α] to identify accreted and in-situ extragalactic globular clusters
Anastasia Gvozdenko, Michael A. Beasley, Katja Fahrion, Søren Larsen, Francesco La Barbera, Alexandre Vazdekis, Ignacio Martín-Navarro
Abstract
The chemical abundance ratio [Eu/α] has been proposed as a discriminator between ex-situ and in-situ stellar populations in the Milky Way and external galaxies. Here we show with a high-quality, homogeneous dataset of integrated-light abundances for 28 globular clusters (GCs), where 21 are extragalactic and 7 galactic, that this behaviour holds in other Local Group galaxies. In particular, we find metal-rich ([Fe/H] > --0.7) M31 GCs have uniformly low [Eu/Si]-0.4, indicating they represent an in-situ population. Lower metallicity GCs in M31 generally show high [Eu/Si] +0.4, suggesting they originated in accreted progenitors, and these GCs lie at larger projected radii from the M31 centre. Furthermore, we compare the M31 GC abundances with similar determinations for the M31 bulge for Na, Mg, Si, Ti, Ca, Eu, Cr, Mn, Ba, Ni, and Cu. The in-situ M31 GCs and M31 bulge exhibit similar abundance trends, excepting Ba -- and possibly Cr and Ti, suggesting similar star formation processes. [Eu/Si] in the M31 bulge is consistent with in-situ Milky Way stars, but is higher than the M31 in-situ GCs. For M33 and intermediate-mass dwarf galaxies, we identify a mixture of in-situ and ex-situ GCs, while for lower-mass dwarfs, we identify primarily in-situ GCs. These results suggest that accreted GCs in massive galaxies originated, at least in part, from intermediate-mass, intermediate-metallicity progenitors. We support earlier suggestions that [Eu/α] is a powerful in-/ex-situ separator for extragalactic GCs, demonstrating the potential of high-resolution integrated-light abundances for extragalactic archaeology.
Create a lesson
Related papers
Every galaxy is a radio source: a stellar-mass dependent minimum 150 MHz luminosity identified in the LoTSS Deep Fields
Shravya Shenoy, Daniel J. B. Smith, Martin J. Hardcastle et al.
Chemical Cartography Across Time: The Age-Dependent Chemical Structure of the Milky Way with a Homogeneous Sample of 580,000 Giants from Five Surveys
Jeff Shen, Neige Frankel, David W. Hogg et al.
The Galaxy Activity, Torus, and Outflow Survey: N. Little Red Dots are not dust deficient: constraints from Seyfert 1 JWST spectra
C. Ramos Almeida, R. Maiolino, I. García-Bernete et al.
Eigenspectra of Poisson-sampled stellar population models: Statistical fingerprints of cool giant stars in unresolved early-type galaxies
Anastasia Gvozdenko, Russell J. Smith
Peanut/X-shaped bulges: Returning to the vertical resonance and separatrix
Sergei A. Rusakov, Viktor D. Zozulia, Natalia Ya. Sotnikova et al.
Dynamics of spinning supermassive black hole binaries: I. A direct N-body study
Navonil Saha, Margarita Sobolenko, Peter Berczik et al.